pxl
bismellah


pixl

Home
Articles
AfghanPedia

Contact Us


Why is America Failing in Afghanistan?

- DR. Abdul-Qayum Mohmand

Analysis of “CIA World Factbook” (1981-2012): Dimensions of anti-Pashtun Conspirac

Afghan Fury at Planned Pakistan Pact
What Happens When the U.S. Leaves Afghanistan?
Trying to leave Afghanistan proves to be as troublesome as being there: A Closer Look
Afghanistan: “It’s Just Damage Limitation Now”
Zero Dark Thirty Review-Analysis; Eleven Instances of Disinformation
Why is America Failing in Afghanistan?
 
 
 
US forces in Afghanistan nearly destroyed vital airfield
We Are Those Two Afghan Children, Killed by NATO While Tending Their Cattle
Former Islamist Warlord Vies for Afghan Presidency
Pakistan releases top Afghan Taliban prisoner in effort to boost peace process
Losing the War in Afghanistan
Obama’s troop increase for Afghan war was misdirected
Afghan security vacuum feared along "gateway to Kabul"
Objections to U.S. Troops Intensify in Afghanistan
The Great Afghan corruption scam
War zone killing: Vets feel 'alone' in their guilt
Was Osama for Real? And Was He Killed in 2001?
Afghanistan withdrawal: The risks of retreat
The Real Reason the US Invaded Afghanistan
The Definition of a Quagmire
Huge Uncertainty' in Afghanistan
Controversial ID Cards Expose Ethnic Divisions In Afghanistan
Afghanistan: The Final Curtain Call for NATO?
Afghanistan After 9/11: A Mission Unaccomplished
Why Should Taliban and Other Insurgents Refrain from Negotiation With the US & NATO? By: Dr Mohammed Daud Miraki, MA, MA, Ph

Exclusive: Karzai family looks to extend boss rule in Afghanistan.

Intrigue in Karzai Family as an Afghan Era Closes
For Afghans, Two Outrages, Two Different Reactions
Double blow to west’s Afghan strategy
Does the Taliban need a diplomatic voice?
Afghanistan: Lessons in War and Peace-building for US
Afghan women opposed by former allies
Q+A - Haqqani: From White House guest to staunch U.S. enemy
Haqqanis: Growth of a militant network -BBC
Afghanistan shelves plans for ambassador accused of fraud
Afghan nominated as ambassador to Britain was accused in US of fraud
U.S. deal with Taliban breaks down
The Loneliness of the Afghan President: Karzai on His Own

NATO's Third Alternative in Afghanistan

On the Road: Interview with Commander Abdul Haq:- The Tragedy of Abdul Haq
When the Lion Roared: How Abdul Haq Almost Saved Afghanistan
AFGHAN WARRIOR: THE LIFE & DEATH OF ABDUL HAQ
Pakistan’s ISI: Undermining Afghan self-determination since 1948
Mineral Wealth of Afghanistan, Military Occupation, Corruption and the Rights of the Afghan People
M. Siddieq Noorzoy
Why Isn’t the UN Investigating and Prosecuting the U.S. and NATO for War Crimes Committed in Afghanistan?
Corruption and Warlordism:
Abdul Basir Stanikzai
In Afghanistan, U.S. contracts aren’t crystal balls, but they come close
The great Afghan carve-up
Anatomy of an Afghan war tragedy
Terry Jones Actually Burns a Qur’an and No One Notices
Q+A-Are Afghan forces ready to take over security?
Guantánamo Bay files rewrite the story of Osama bin Laden's Tora Bora escape
Winning Afghan hearts, minds with explosives
Afghanistan’s Mercenaries
KABUL’S HORIZONS
Who is winning Afghanistan war? U.S. officials increasingly disagree
Afghanistan: The Trouble With The Transition
From the Archives: In Quest of a ‘Greater Tajikistan’
The 1980s mujahideen, the Taliban and the shifting idea of jihad
Afghanistan's Karzai complains about interference
Karzai, US ambassador at odds over private security

Karzai Tells Washington Post U.S. Should Reduce Afghan Operation Intensity

Excerpts from Afghan President Hamid Karzai's interview with The Washington Post
What the Afghans Want
New US approach to Afghanistan insurgency: Vindication for Pakistan?
Putting Some Fight Into Our Friends
Afghans 'abused at secret prison
Why We Won’t Leave Afghanistan or Iraq
Indo-Pakistan proxy war heats up in Afghanistan
Canada’s elite commandos and the invasion of Afghanistan
U.S. retreat from Afghan valley marks recognition of blunder
Five myths about the war in Afghanistan
Marine who resigned over ‘conscience’ speaks at MU
The Afghan media may have grown since Taliban rule ended, but not so press freedoms
Mystery holes and angry ants: another Afghan day
Kabul Bank's Sherkhan Farnood feeds crony capitalism in Afghanistan
Marjah War
Operation Moshtarak: Which way the war in Afghanistan?
Q&A: Why Marjah, why now?
In Jalalabad, hope is fading
Seeking reconciliation, US units meet remote Afghanistan tribes
Once Again, Get the Hell Out! "Ending the War in Afghanistan"
Blackwater Kept a Prostitute on the Payroll in Afghanistan; Fraudulently Billed American Tax Payers
Wild West Motif Lightens US Mood at Afghan Bas
In southern Afghanistan, even the small gains get noticed
 Afghanistan war: US tries to undercut Taliban at tribal level
 Soviet lessons from Afghanistan
Are actions of 'super-tribe' an Afghan tipping point
Taliban: Terrorist or not? Not always easy to say
Q&A: Who else could help in Afghanistan?
Vietnam Replay on Afghan 'Defectors'
Washington's Refusal to Talk about Drone Strikes in Pakistan Meets Growing Opposition
Afghanistan summit: Why is the US backing talks with the Taliban?
Taliban's leadership council runs Afghan war from Pakistan
Why buy the Taliban?
2 Afghanistan conferences: No solutions
An Alternative to Endless War - Negotiating an Afghan Agreement?
Do the Taliban represent the Pashtuns?
Afghanistan asks ex-presidential contender to tackle corruption

Tehran Sets Conditions For Attending London Conference On Afghanista

Pakistan says reaches out to Afghan Taliban
Taking It to the Taliban
The Afghan Taliban's top leaders
How significant is Mullah Baradar's arrest?
Secret Joint Raid Captures Taliban’s Top Commander
What's the Quetta Shura Taliban and why does it matter?
What's behind latest Taliban attack on Kabul? See Images of the Attack By WSJ

Pakistan Version of Islam and Taliban ?????
Lahore fashion week takes on Talibanization in Pakistan

Loyalties of Those Killed in Afghan Raid Remain Unclear

After Attack, Afghans Question Motives or See Conspiracies
Gates: Taliban part of Afghan ‘political fabric’

IG: Afghan power-plant project ill-conceived, mismanaged

Taliban intensifies Afghan PR campaign

Taliban Overhaul Their Image in Bid to Win Allies
Karzai plans to woo Taliban with 'land, work and pensions'
Peace scheme mooted for Taliban
Bombs and baksheesh
But By All Means, Continue the Happy Talk on the Afghanistan War
Karzai Closing in on Taliban Reconciliation Plan
Last Exit Kabul
How To Get Out Without Forsaking Afghanistan's Stability
Afghan Recovery Report: Taleban Buying Guns From Former Warlords

'Jesus Guns': Two More Countries Rethink Using Weapons with Secret Bible References

Gun bible quotes 'inappropriate'
Text of Joint declaration of Afghanistan-Iran-Pakistan trilateral meeting
Garmsir Protest Shows Taleban Reach
Rugged North Waziristan harbors US enemies
The Arrogance of Empire, Detailed ( The Untold Story of Afghanistan )
Appointment of Afghan counter narcotics chief dismays British officials
In Afghanistan attack, CIA fell victim to series of miscalculations about informant
Rebuilding Afghanistan: Will government take hold in this post-Taliban town?
Rare bird discovered in Afghan mountains
Blackwater, now called Xe, in running for work in Afghanistan despite legal woes
How Soviet troops stormed Kabul palace
Afghan children 'die in fighting'
Afghanistan war: Russian vets look back on their experience
U.N. Officials Say American Offered Plan to Replace Karzai 
Learning From the Soviets
U.S. faults Afghan corruption body's independence
Intensify fight against corruption, says Afghan meeting
Afghan ministers cleared of charges
Drone aircraft in a stepped-up war in Afghanistan and Pakistan
U.S. Air Force Confirms 'Beast of Kandahar' Secret Stealth Drone Plane
Kissinger's fantasy is Obama's realit
Taliban shadow officials offer concrete alternative
Talking with the Taliban
20. Ashraf Ghani and Clare Lockhart
'Yes, there was torture and people were certainly beaten': Afghan warden
Why we should leave Afghanistan
US pours millions into anti-Taliban militias in Afghanistan
Pakistan to US: Don't surge in Afghanistan, talk to Taliban
A Plan C for Afghanistan
Finding decent cabinet is Karzai's big challenge
A way to get around Karzai in Afghanistan
Corruption fight boosted by 'Afghan FBI'
US demands Afghan 'bribery court'
Afghanistan plans court for corrupt ministers
The man leading Afghanistan's anti-corruption fight
Win hearts and minds in Afghanistan to win the war
Gates blocks abuse photos release
New U.S. Afghan prison unveiled, rights groups wary
War in Afghanistan: Not in our name
How the US Funds the Taliban
Afghan gov't says UN representative out of line
Cabinet of Warlords
Afghanistan and the lessons of history
Clinton says Karzai ‘must do better’
Recognizing the Limits of American Power in Afghanistan
After Afghanistan election, governors seek distance from 'illegal' Karzai
Karzai was hellbent on victory. Afghans will pay the price
Matthew Hoh: Please refute what I'm saying, we are stuck in the Afghan civil war
As US looks for exit in Afghanistan, China digs in
America's Top Diplomat Tells 'Nightline': 'Not Every Taliban Is al Qaeda'
Obama Can’t Make Russian Mistake in Afghanistan
10 Steps to Victory in Afghanistan
Will Obama change Afghan strategy?
Does the U.S. still have a vital interest in Afghanistan?
Pashtuns and Pakistani
The Afghan '80s are back
Pashtun peace prophet goes global
Afghan Road Builder's Dream Thwarted by Violence
A white elephant in Kabul
The Afghan Runoff: Will It Be a No-Show Election?

Ashraf Ghani- Afghanistan's Disputed Election Complicates U.S. Strategy

On Assignment: Into the Maw at Marja

Patrick Witty & Tyler Hicks
The New York Times


Afghanistan Cross Road CNN


The last frontier


Bruce Richardson
 

Articles

CIA: Buying peace in Afghanistan?

With Bags of Cash, C.I.A. Seeks Influence in Afghanistan
CIA Ghost Money: Karzai Confirms U.S. Gives Funds To Afghan National Security Team
What the CIA’s cash has bought for Afghanistan

Khalilzad: A Satan Whispering in the Hearts of Men
The Afghan trust deficitt
Will We Learn Anything from Afghanistan? Part 1
Getting Out of Afghanistan: Part 2
William R. Polk
General’s Defense on Afghan Scandal Ducks Key Evidence
Afghans want Taliban peace talks
Bombing Weddings in Afghanistan: It Couldn't Happen Here, It Does Happen There
Hekmatyar's never-ending Afghan war
Covert American Aid to the Afghan Resistance; A Top-Secret U.S. Foreign Policy Plot to Induce and Effect Soviet Military Intervention
Afghan brain drain fears as Karzai urges education reforms

US considers launching joint US-Afghan raids in Pakistan to hunt down militant groups

Real security in Afghanistan depends on people's basic needs being met
Intractable Afghan Graft Hampering U.S. Strategy
Former Taliban Officials Say U.S. Talks Started
Taliban ready for talks with US, not Karzai government
Emboldened Taliban Try to Sell Softer Image
Leaked NATO Report Shows Pakistan Support For Taliban
Insight: Few options for Afghan, U.S. leaders after Kandahar massacre
Presenter: Secretary of Defense Leon E. Panetta and Daoud Sultanzoy, Tolo Television
NATO’s measured exit plan in Afghanistan faces new obstacles
BFP Exclusive: Karzai Clan Attorney Threatens US Journalist, Uses Intimidation Tactics
Afghanistan Chronicles
Arduous path to Afghan 'end-game'
Fear in the classrooms: is the Taliban poisoning Afghanistan's schoolgirls?
A comment on the recent events of student poisoning in Afghanistan
Rape Case, in Public, Cites Abuse by Armed Groups in Afghanistan
Afghanistan’s Peace Talks Hit Brick Wall
THE ANATOMY OF US’S DEFEAT IN AFGHANISTAN
VOICES OF EMPIRE: FROM CIA’s CULTURAL GREAT GAME TO GLOBAL GREAT GAME TODAY
WHITE PAPER FOR THE PERMANENT PEACE IN AFGHANISTAN
King Karzai
A Federal System of Government is Not Suitable for Afghanistan
CHINA AMO DARYA OIL DEAL
Analysis: Where Afghan humanitarianism ends and development begins
U.S. Envoy: Kabulbank Was 'Vast Looting Scheme'
Speaking with the enemy: how US commanders fight the Taliban during the day and dine with them at night
Afghanistan: Operation Enduring Musery
How to Win Peace in Afghanistan
For Karzai, Stumbles On Road To Election
Cruel human toll of fight to win Afghan peace
Criticism of Afghan War Is on the Rise in Britain
Troops 'fighting for UK's future'
Operation in Taliban hotbed a test for revamped U.S. strategy
Covering Crucial Afghanistan Operation
Afghans still skeptical about Obama
US Defence Department struggling with public release of report on bombing in Afghanistan
Afghanistan on the Edge
Q+A: Who are the Pakistani Taliban insurgents?
Afghanistan Past & Present
Bombs for Pashtoons and Dollars for Punjab
Help! I'm being outgunned on K Street!
ANGELS CHASING DEMONS: “Jesus Killed Mohammad”!
U.S. tested 2 Afghan scenarios in war game
America's Top Diplomat Tells 'Nightline': 'Not Every Taliban Is al Qaeda'
Obama hearing range of views on Afghanistan
What Do Afghans Want? Withdrawal - But Not Too Fast - and A Negotiated Peace
Will Obama change Afghan strategy?
What Do Afghans Want? Withdrawal - But Not Too Fast - and A Negotiated Peace
Afghans tricked into U.S. trip, detained
In the Afghan War, Aim for the Middle
Obama pulled two ways in Afghanistan
Obama Can’t Make Russian Mistake in Afghanistan
10 Steps to Victory in Afghanistan
Gates: Mistake to set time line for Afghan withdrawal
Afghans question what democracy has done for them
High stakes in Afghan vote recount
Two Perspectives On Resolving The Afghan Postelection Crisis
Does the U.S. still have a vital interest in Afghanistan?
Pashtuns and Pakistanis
The Afghan '80s are back
How to Lose in Afghanistan
US in Afghanistan proposes revamped strategy
US 'needs fresh Afghan strategy'
US looks to Vietnam for Afghan tips
Lessons from Vietnam on Afghanistan
Afghan Pres. Skips Country's 1st TV Debate
A proud moment for Afghanistan
Rival to Karzai Gains Strength in Afghan Presidential Election
Afghan presidential candidate withdraws in Karzai's favor
America and international law
Hamid Karzai pulls out of historic TV debate just hours before broadcast
Karzai says no to first Afghanpresidential debate
Afghan election: Can Karzai's rivals close the gap?
Karzai opponents hope to beat him in second round
Afghanistan's Election Challenges
For Karzai, Stumbles On Road To Election
Pentagon Seeks to Overhaul Prisons in Afghanistan
Cruel human toll of fight to win Afghan peace
Karzai’s gimmick
Well-known traffickers set free ahead of election
US president sets Afghan target
U.S. Inaction Seen After Taliban P.O.W.’s Died
Why the Pentagon Axed Its Afghanistan Warlord
Earn our trust or go, Afghans tell GIs
The Irresistible Illusion
Running Out Of Options, Afghans Pay For an Exit
We've lost sight of our goal in Afghanistan
$2,000 for a dead Afghan Child, $100,000 for Any American Who Died Killing it
The strategy is sound – but success is not assured
Operation in Taliban hotbed a test for revamped U.S. strategy
Covering Crucial Afghanistan Operation
Pentagon Seeks to Overhaul Prisons in Afghanistan
Echoes of Vietnam
A Response To General Dostum
Obama orders probe of killings in Afghanistan
Obama admin: No grounds to probe Afghan war crimes
US president sets Afghan target
U.S. Inaction Seen After Taliban P.O.W.’s Died
Afghanistan's Election Challenges
The Irresistible Illusion
Earn our trust or go, Afghans tell GIs
Running Out Of Options, Afghans Pay For an Exit

We've lost sight of our goal in Afghanistan

The strategy is sound – but success is not assured
Stakes High in Afghanistan Ahead of August Elections
$2,000 for a dead Afghan Child, $100,000 for Any American Who Died Killing it
Ex-detainees allege Bagram abuse
Petraeus Is a Failure -- Why Do We Pretend He's Been a Success?
Fierce Battles and High Casualties on the Frontlines of Afghanistan
End the Illegal, Immoral and Wasted War in Afghanistan, says BNP Defence Spokesman
Outside View: Four revolutions
Pakistan's Plans for New Fight Stir Concern
France: liberty, equality, and fraternity – but no burqas
 

 

 

 

 

Echoes of Vietnam

Even the Coalition commanders in Afghanistan wonder if they can win the war
Will history repeat itself in Afghanistan?

British military intervention in Afghanistan has a chequered history, making it easy to conclude that British forces will fail again


 


The Costs of War Taking Afghanistan as a Case Study
Source: M. Siddieq Noorzoy, Emeritus Professor of Economics

Summary and Revision of the Paper Given at the Business and Economics Conference, Oxford, University, July 1-2, 2017

A Conference Paper Intended for Presentation at the

Oxford Business and Economics Conference
Oxford University, UK, July 1-2, 2017
M. Siddieq Noorzoy, Emeritus Professor of Economics
Department of Economics, University of Alberta
Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

Since the writing of the paper early in the year new developments have taken place in the war in Afghanistan and ,thus, impacting the costs of the war. These statements and estimates are subject to revision.

It is a truism that the longer a war fought and the more intensely the higher the costs of the war. Both of these criteria apply for discussing and possibly measuring the costs of the wars in Afghanistan. The present war in Afghanistan started with the US led invasion on October 7, 2001, the longest war for the US and for Afghanistan. But for Afghanistan the present war was preceded first by the Soviet invasion on December 24, 1979 for a decade which was followed by civil wars before the US led invasion. Thus in Afghanistan there are the cumulative effects of these wars going on for 37 years and the costs of these wars have piled up on the Afghan people and on Afghanistan in all areas.

On April 13, 2017 an unexpected event took place in the war; viz., CNN and other media sources reported on April 13-14, 2017, that the Mother of All Bombs  (MOAB ) weighing 21,600 pounds  and 30 ft. long was dropped on the Achin district of eastern Afghanistan; the largest non-nuclear bomb used for the first time in war. This bomb was bigger in size than either of the atomic bombs dropped on Japan in 1945. The full effects and implications of this action by the US against Afghanistan are not known especially on the people and on the environment.

https://www.bing.com/images/search?q=mother+of+all+bombs+dropped+on+afghanistan&id=6D844DFC052DD58833852D60C774243A1439ED4C&FORM=IQFRBA

Many condemned this act including Hamid Karzai who had supported the invasion, and occupation saying “this is not the war on terror but the inhuman and most brutal misuse of our country as testing ground for new and dangerous weapons,”  Twitter  ( NYT April 14 2017 Asia Pacific).   

Currently Donald Trump has no declared strategy for ending the war. He has let he generals decide and there are expectations that another 5,000 US troops will be sent to enter the war. It is likely we will see more aerial attacks including the use of heavy bombers.  The Taliban have steadily gained  grounds in the fighting and now it is clear that the Afghan people are backing them across the country. The Taliban hold as much as 40% of the territory declared by the US Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR) earlier in the year. They lost their government when the US and British invaded on October 7, 2001. They ruled most of Afghanistan during 1996-2001. They eliminated poppy cultivation and were recognized as a government by Saudi Arabia, UAE and Pakistan before they were toppled.

 Based on political public discussions America cannot afford to repeat sending a force of 140,000 along with another 40,000-50,000 from the NATO countries and ISAF, consisting of  a ‘coalition of the willing’ of  45 countries, which took place at the height of intense fighting in 2010 when Barack Obama had sent the additional force of 30,000 in a major surge in 2009. Many members of the coalition have second thoughts about the war and have not declared support for renewed fighting. The only hope to end the war is through peace making and end of occupation. 

The Afghan people have always pushed back successfully against foreign occupation including the British and against the former Soviet Union. Gen. Mattis, US Secretary of Defense, has declared  “we are not  winning” the war and before him Gen.  Nicholson the US-NATO Commander had declared the war is “ a stalemate”. These statements and the conditions on the ground in Afghanistan should lead to peace making, the Afghan people hope and expect. So do the people in America.

The Broader Costs of the War and Arguments against the War

This war has failed to bring peace, security, development, and justice. The costs to the Afghan society in each area have been significant and rising. The failing regime in Kabul with infighting, the massive number of refugees, the rampant corruption and rising crime, the deepening poverty, and massive unemployment, the abuse of power and  neglect of the very needy, and the drug problem never experienced before are all costs to the Afghan society and economy.  In many areas the costs are incalculable. For example, the severe drug problem where between 2-3 million Afghans have become addicted especially the young since 2002 in the post invasion year when the cultivation of poppies and manufacturing of opioids mushroomed is nearly impossible to estimate. These costs are observable and they will impact the society in the long run.

Without peace security cannot be established and without development in the broader economy many social programs and social justice will not be attained. A handful has become very rich and powerful while the masses linger on with subsistence level living. There are private and social costs involved which cannot easily be estimated.  Again they are observable and are long run costs.

Where are the Costs Concentrated?

Afghanistan is mostly mountainous, and rural with 78- 80 % of the estimated population of 28-31 million living in some 40,000 villages spread al over the country.  Both of these figures are estimates. Both the Soviet war and the US led war have been fought mainly against the rural communities. There are estimates of the damage done during the Soviet war. But, there are no estimates for the present war which has been fought in the southern and eastern provinces of Afghanistan. For the Soviet war estimates are available drawn from the surveys done under the direction of the late Dr. Azam Gul, during the war referenced in my recent book:

The Afghan Economy during the Soviet War, April 22, 2016, Xlibris.com, Chapter I, Tables 8-9.

Estimates about the number of villages destroyed ( 11,412) and the percentage losses for the animal stocks are given in these tables along with the discussions.  The Soviet war policy was to depopulate villages since the Resistance ( Mujahideen) was drawn from the villages. For the present war the US and NATO war policy has been to remove areas of Resistance ( the Taliban) through aerial attacks and night raids. Both super power wars failed to achieve their goals which meant the rural communities and all their means of living were severely impacted and the full impact of the present war continues and remains largely unknown. The refugees from the present war in Kabul and elsewhere may provide the needed information.

Estimates are not available about the harm done to the villages during the present war since 2001; no similar surveys have been made nor has extensive reporting been done by the media to determine the effects of this war. The media has been kept out of the war zones.

Socially Displaced Costs of the War

The costs of the wars to the Afghan society are more observable and measurable from the refugee and IDP population as a distinct part of the society. The Afghan society impacted by war cannot absorb its refugee population and have the refugees gainfully employed. This measure of the impact of the wars increased over time and clearly is of much concern for peace, security and development. New  internally displaced persons numbered  30,0000 were added  resulting to 1.3 million displaced in 2016 and another 90,000 were added during the first quarter of 2017 UN reports show.

 More than 4.3 million did return from Pakistan and Iran during 2002-2005 and many of them are part of the long term displaced Afghans being unemployed. There are still large numbers of Afghan refugees in Pakistan and Iran who cannot return due to the conditions in Afghanistan. There is continued high unemployment of 40-60 percent throughout much of the country and the accompanying high levels of prevalent poverty. These are costs of the war, but, cannot be readily measured.

Since the departure of most of the foreign contingents at the end of 2014 the demand for the sector that served the foreign forces and recycled the income throughout the rest of the Afghan economy has dried up.  On top of the costs of the war per se, such a collapse in income has had dramatic impact.

The Director of the UN Office of Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs  ( OCHA) recently stated in Kabul that,  “more than nine million people in Afghanistan – one third of the population – are food insecure; an average of 165 children under the age of five die every day; and an Afghan woman dies every two hours due to pregnancy-related causes.
One of the most dramatic impacts of the costs of the wars has been the reduction in the average life span in Afghanistan. The average life span has been lower by 10-15 years among the Afghan people in comparison to all of the neighboring countries with common borders with Afghanistan. The claim that life expectancy has been raised to 60 years during the last decade or so is not substantiated.

Office of the UNOCHA, stated that 80 percent of the 1.6 million Afghan refugees in Pakistan do not want to repatriate to Afghanistan due to insecurity, lack of jobs and lack of official support for resettlement.  These conditions are costs of the war. They cannot be estimated in monetary terms.

Revising the results of their study the WATSON INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL AND PUBLIC AFFAIRS at Brown University, Providence, RI., provided the following findings: 

    Summary of Findings         (2001-2016) 

Some of the Costs of War Project’s main findings include:
Estimated 370,000 people have died due to direct war violence, including armed forces on all sides of the conflicts, contractors, civilians, journalists, and humanitarian workers.  It is likely that many times more than 370,000 people have died indirectly in these wars, due to malnutrition, damaged infrastructure, and environmental degradation. 200,000 civilians have been killed in direct violence by all parties to these conflicts.

10.1 million Afghans, Iraqis, and [ trible Pushtuns between Afghanistan and ]Pakistan are living as war refugees and internally displaced persons, in grossly inadequate conditions. The wars have been accompanied by erosions in civil liberties and human rights.

US government funding of reconstruction efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan has totaled over $170 billion. Most of those funds have gone towards arming security forces in both countries. Much of the money allocated to humanitarian relief and rebuilding civil society has been lost to fraud, waste, and abuse.

For the US the cost for the Iraq and Afghanistan/Pakistan wars totals about $4.8 trillion. This does not include future interest costs on borrowing for the wars, which will add an estimated $8 trillion through 2054.

The Costs of wars in Afghanistan in Terms of Population Losses

For Afghanistan at least 100,000 Afghans have been killed . Indirectly probably another 100,000 have been killed due to the indirect effects of the war if we assume the same proportionality used by the Watson Institute in making their direct and indirect estimate of the human costs of the war since 2001. Estimates of the annual number of Afghans killed during 2001-2014 are provided from Wikipedia in the body of the paper.  They are subject to revisions as more facts are discovered. During the Soviet war estimates are that 150,000 Afghans were killed yearly during 1979-1989 and the total may have been 1.95 million killed and 1.5 million may have been disabled or wounded.(Cf., Chap. 9 and the Appendix , The Afghan Economy during the Soviet War, op. cit.). 

Alternatives to War

Due to the fact that many have written about the illegality of these wars it goes without saying that the costs of these wars could have been avoided had the Bush Administration and certainly the Obama Administration had used diplomacy rather than war.

Alter The team carrying out the work under the Eisenhower Research Project ,  Cost of War , they cite in their summary of findings that the alternative to war was not considered by the Bush Administration before invading  Afghanistan and Iraq.  In their statement “alternatives to war”, they cite “success of various methods used against groups using terror tactics in 268 cases during 1968-2006” presenting the following results: 

1)            Peaceful political accommodation                                                        43%
2)            Intelligence and police methods                                                           40%
3)            Group achieved its objective by violence and ceased its activities         10%
4)            Military defeat                                                                                      7%

The Estimate of the Costs of the War during the Soviet Invasion and War Drawn from the Appendix of the Book: The Afghan Economy during the Soviet War
 Here the focal point are the losses during the war and occupation years as well as the communist rule. These estimates should be considered as a baseline measure and as such are preliminary. However, much of these estimates are founded on actual losses in different areas based on years of research and findings. Any new findings will in all likelihood show that the losses were greater than estimated in this study. For this reason the estimates here should be considered as the minimum for any legal proceedings for the demand for war damages.

The Estimated Costs of War Inflicted upon Afghanistan during 1979-1989
The Human Costs:
Estimated Losses in Income from Wrongful Death- $195.11 billion
Estimated Costs Experienced by the Disabled Persons-$37.50 billion
Estimated Costs of Population Dislocation and Resettlement-$50.0 billion
Estimated Costs of the Losses in Human Capital -$10 billion
Destruction of Property:
Replacement Costs of Houses Destroyed- $10.452 billion
Replacement Costs of Villages Destroyed-$ 114.180 million
Replacement Costs of Schools Destroyed-$32.61 million
Replacement Costs of Animal Stocks Destroyed-$5 billion
Replacement costs of the damage to the infrastructure-$ 5 billion
Losses to the Afghan Economy:
Destruction of the Growth Prospect of the Economy and
Losses from Trade Diversion-$ 5 billion
Losses from Gas Exports and Mineral Exploitations Estimated at $1.039 billion.

There are no estimates on the possible exploitation of mineral resources of Afghanistan. However, there are reasons to believe it did take place USSR export statistics data to Afghanistan which showed the value of exports of machinery and equipment for mineral exploitation as translated, but, there were no statistics for the years noted on any import of mineral resources to the USSR from Afghanistan. Thus, the question remains till today,

 The surveys for mineral explorations were carried by teams of Afghans and Soviet geologists in prior decades. For the purpose of this study an unknown amount of loss from possible extraction and exports of unrecorded mineral resources is represented by the symbol X and is included in the overall equation measuring losses. All other losses including destruction of institutions, harm from the millions of mines laid, probable use of chemical weapons, tens of thousands of Afghan children kidnapped are given by the symbol Y amount.

Thus, Total losses inflicted on Afghanistan, its economy and society at least amounted to: $ 319.2478 billion + X +Y.    More information in the areas defined by the symbols X and Y are required to monetize the losses experienced by Afghanistan. 

References and Recent Works by the author on Afghanistan:
NATO : “The war in Afghanistan- an open letter”  May 24, 2017, www.Dawat.net   ,  and www.Sabawoo.com  .
Campaigns by the Afghan Diaspora on Behalf of Afghanistan, September 1979-August 2015, forthcoming
The Afghan Economy during the Soviet War, Xlibris.com also on Amazon.com, April, 2016
“ Afghanistan’s Wartime Economy  2001-2014…”   www.Globalresearch.org ,  July 24, 2014

 

The articles and letters are the opinion of the writers and are not representing the view of Sabawoon Online.
Copyright © 1996 - 2017 Sabawoon. All rights reserved.